Table 5 Comparison between Periodontal effects outcomes of MARPE and SARME
Periodontal outcomes | MARPE | SARME | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lin22 (between 1st PM to 2nd M) | Moon19 (1st M) | Li20 (1st M) | Sygourus23 (between 1st PM to 1st M) | Gauthier24 (between 1st PM to 2nd M) | Kayalar21 (1st PM/1 M) | ||||||
Bone-Borne | Bone-Borne | Tooth-Bone-Borne | Tooth-Bone-Borne | Tooth-Borne | Tooth Borne | Tooth-Borne | Tooth-Bone-Borne | ||||
C-Expander | C-Expander | MSE | G1 (MSE II) Bicortical | G2 (MSE II) Monocortical and bicortical | G3 (MSE II) Monocortical | +PD Hyrax-Acrylic | -PD Hyrax-Acrylic | Hyrax | Hyrax | Hybrid Hyrax | |
Alveolar Bending | 0.92° | 2.32° | 0.81° | 0.5° | 1.05° | 2.05° | 5.45° | 7.34° | – | – | – |
Dental inclination | 0.87° | 0.07° | 2.4° | 0.7° | 1.35° | 4.8 | 5.03° | 5.56° | – | 2.01°/3.77° | −0.63°/3.11° |
Alveolar crest height | −0.24 mm | −1.24 mm | −1.33 mm | −0.6 mm | −0.65 mm | −0.6 mm | 0.31 mm | 0.47 mm | −1.42 mm | – | – |
Buccal alveolar bone thickness | – | −0.07 mm | − 0.58 mm | – | – | – | − 0.51 mm | − 0.86 mm | − 0.55 mm | − 0.55 mm/− 0.61 mm | − 0.2 mm/− 0.64 mm |
Palatal Alveolar bone thickness | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | 0.85 mm | 1.02 mm/1.14 mm | − 0.05 mm/0.8 mm |
Dehiscence | 0.22 mm | 2 of 48 (4.2%) | 15 of 48 (31.3%) | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | – |
Fenestration | – | 1 of 48 | 6 of 48 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | – |