Skip to main content

Table 13 Descriptive statistics - three methods per components

From: Measurement error and reliability of three available 3D superimposition methods in growing patients

    95% Confidence interval
Landmarks Superimposition method Mean (mm) Lower bound Upper bound
ANS R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.057 −0.140 0.254
Landmark-derived Method 0.185 −0.622 0.992
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.096 −0.146 0.338
ANS A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 1.103 0.582 1.625
Landmark-derived Method 1.146 0.435 1.856
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 1.210 0.730 1.690
ANS S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −1.717 −2.130 −1.305
Landmark-derived Method −4.373 −5.604 −3.142
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −1.680 −2.060 − 1.301
A-Point R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.036 −0.165 0.237
Landmark-derived Method 0.223 −0.546 0.992
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.127 −0.079 0.333
A-Point A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.628 0.279 0.978
Landmark-derived Method 0.534 −0.081 1.150
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.786 0.430 1.141
A-Point S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −1.900 −2.410 −1.390
Landmark-derived Method −4.503 −5.742 −3.265
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −2.076 −2.617 −1.536
PNS R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −0.064 −0.238 0.110
Landmark-derived Method −0.079 −0.398 0.240
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.092 −0.108 0.292
PNS A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −0.151 − 0.515 0.214
Landmark-derived Method −0.650 −1.156 −0.144
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −0.124 − 0.522 0.274
PNS S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −1.217 − 1.528 −0.905
Landmark-derived Method −1.974 −2.537 −1.411
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −1.115 −1.394 −0.836
Orbitale Right R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.192 −0.045 0.428
Landmark-derived Method 0.353 −0.455 1.162
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.018 −0.083 0.120
Orbitale Right A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.964 0.667 1.262
Landmark-derived Method 1.164 0.644 1.685
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 1.076 0.788 1.363
Orbitale Right S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.126 0.108 0.360
Landmark-derived Method 2.054 0.980 3.129
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.105 0.145 0.354
Orbitale Left R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −0.074 −0.213 0.064
Landmark-derived Method −0.404 −1.268 0.460
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −0.084 − 0.217 0.049
Orbitale Left A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 1.055 0.735 1.376
Landmark-derived Method 1.358 0.938 1.778
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 1.217 0.942 1.492
Orbitale Left S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.198 0.017 0.413
Landmark-derived Method 2.057 0.967 3.148
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.242 0.053 0.431
Menton R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −0.117 −0.445 0.211
Landmark-derived Method 0.247 −0.691 1.185
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.013 −0.323 0.349
Menton A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.900 0.159 1.641
Landmark-derived Method 1.122 0.521 2.765
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.994 0.272 1.716
Menton S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −4.922 −5.680 −4.163
Landmark-derived Method −7.144 −8.534 −5.755
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −4.964 −5.719 − 4.208
B-Point R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −0.042 −0.402 0.318
Landmark-derived Method 0.132 −0.832 1.097
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.000 −0.353 0.353
B-Point A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 0.711 0.064 1.358
Landmark-derived Method 0.794 0.559 2.148
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 0.786 0.144 1.428
B-Point S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −3.812 −4.535 −3.090
Landmark-derived Method −5.854 −7.369 −4.339
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −3.832 −4.555 − 3.109
Gonion Right R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 1.296 0.996 1.596
Landmark-derived Method 1.496 1.078 1.915
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 1.404 1.109 1.699
Gonion Right A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −1.205 −1.764 −0.646
Landmark-derived Method −2.651 −3.994 −1.308
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −0.977 −1.504 −0.451
Gonion Right S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −3.536 −4.252 −2.820
Landmark-derived Method −3.638 −4.435 −2.840
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −3.841 −4.522 −3.160
Gonion Left R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −1.230 −1.519 −0.941
Landmark-derived Method −1.130 −1.462 −0.797
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −1.069 −1.399 −0.740
Gonion Left A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −1.396 −2.042 −0.750
Landmark-derived Method −2.135 −3.083 −1.186
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −0.989 −1.522 −0.455
Gonion Left S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −3.138 −3.857 −2.419
Landmark-derived Method −3.929 −4.753 −3.105
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −3.696 −4.362 −3.031
Pogonion R-L Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −0.037 −0.381 0.306
Landmark-derived Method 0.063 −1.068 1.193
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −0.001 −0.329 0.327
Pogonion A-P Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method 1.025 0.322 1.729
Landmark-derived Method 0.115 −1.753 1.983
Voxel-based Dolphin Method 1.095 0.422 1.769
Pogonion S-I Voxel-Based CMFreg/Slicer Method −4.216 −4.949 −3.483
Landmark-derived Method −5.746 −8.723 −2.770
Voxel-based Dolphin Method −4.425 −5.087 −3.762