Skip to main content

Table 4 Prevalence and percentage agreement between physical exam and 2D image ratings, intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) estimates, and agreement on surgery history for each facial feature. Features are listed in decreasing order of the estimated ICC

From: Reliable classification of facial phenotypic variation in craniofacial microsomia: a comparison of physical exam and photographs

Craniofacial feature Prevalence by PE ratings: proportion (%)a Prevalence by 2D ratings: proportion (%)a Agreement between PE and 2D ratings: proportion (%) Intraclass correlation coefficient (95 % CI) Agreement on surgery history: (%)
Dermoid 4/78 (5 %) 3/78 (4 %) 77/78, (99 %) 0.85 (0.51, 1) 99 %
Ear 35/77 (46 %) 36/76 (47 %) 70/76, 92 %) 0.81 (0.51, 1) 99 %
Coloboma 2/234 (1 %) 3/228 (1 %) 227/228, (99 %) 0.80 (0.32, 1) 100 %
Ear canal 24/75 (32 %) 28/65 (43 %) 54/62, (87 %) 0.73 (0.56, 0.89) 97 %
Occlusal plane 12/66 (18 %) 8/63 (13 %) 56/61, (92 %) 0.69 (0.35, 1) 100 %
Mandible & Soft Tissue 46/156 (30 %) 36/155 (23 %) 135/155, (87 %) 0.67 (0.48, 0.86) 97 %
Palsy 24/300 (8 %) 12/263 (5 %) 250/261, (96 %) 0.65 (0.35, 0.95) 100 %
Tags 15/214 (7 %) 26/223 (12 %) 196/210, (93 %) 0.61 (0.39, 0.83) 90 %
Lateral Oral Cleft 7/77 (9 %) 6/77 (8 %) 72/77, (94 %) 0.58 (0.13, 1) 97 %
Cleft lip 3/78 (4 %) 1/72 (1 %) 70/72, (97 %) 0.48 (0, 1) 100 %
Orbital displacement 10/73 (14 %) 16/78 (20 %) 60/73, (82 %) 0.38 (0, 0.81) 100 %
Strabismus 0/77 (0 %) 2/77 (3 %) 75/76, (99 %) 0.17 (0, 1) 100 %
Tongue 2/78 (3 %) 4/64 (6 %) 58/64, (91 %) 0.07 (0, 0.32) 100 %
Pits 4/229 (2 %) 3/224 (1 %) 215/222, (97 %) 0.07 (0, 0.23) 96 %
Orbital size 3/78 (4 %) 1/78 (1 %) 74/78, (95 %) 0 (NA) 100 %
  1. an/N (%): where N is number of ratings, n is number of positive ratings, and the percentage of positive ratings is listed in the brackets